Got roof questions?

Can I pick my own roofer, or does insurance choose?

After a hail or wind storm, a lot of owners think the insurance company decides who fixes the roof. It doesn't. Here's how it really works, in plain English.

The full answer

Insurance pays. You choose.

Your insurance company does not get to choose your roofer. Their job is to inspect the damage through an adjuster, decide what your policy covers, and pay for those covered repairs. Who does the work is your decision.

Some carriers will hand you a list of "preferred" or "network" contractors. That list is a suggestion. You don't have to use anyone on it, and many states have rules that bar insurers from requiring a specific repair company.

What matters to your insurer is the scope and cost of the repair, not the name on the truck. A good roofer documents the damage, writes a clear repair scope, and can back up every line of it to your adjuster.

Who does what

Three players, three jobs

Insurance company

Decides coverage

  • Sends an adjuster to inspect
  • Decides what your policy covers
  • Pays the covered amount, minus your deductible
You, the owner

Makes the call

  • Files the claim with your insurer
  • Chooses the roofer and signs the contract
  • Approves the roof system and the work
Your roofer

Proves it & builds it

  • Inspects and documents storm damage
  • Writes the repair scope and estimate
  • Builds the roof system to code
The order of things

How a storm claim usually goes

  1. Get inspected

    Have a trained inspector check the whole roof system before you file.

  2. File the claim

    Call your insurance company and report the storm date.

  3. Meet the adjuster

    Your roofer can be on the roof with the adjuster to show the damage.

  4. Pick your roofer

    Choose who you trust, review the scope, and sign.

  5. Build the roof

    Work gets done, final paperwork goes to your insurer.

Good to know

Before you sign with anyone

Preferred lists are optional

A carrier's contractor list is a convenience. Saying "no thanks" does not hurt your claim.

Price differences get documented

If your roofer's scope differs from the adjuster's estimate, it's handled with photos, measurements and line items, not by switching roofers.

Your deductible is yours

Be wary of anyone who offers to "cover" or "waive" your deductible. It's illegal in some states and can put your claim at risk.

The mortgage company may be on the check

Insurance checks often name your lender too. That's normal and doesn't change who you can hire.

Read your policy

A small number of policies give the insurer an option to handle repairs. If yours does, it will say so in writing.

Watch for storm chasers

Check that the roofer is licensed, insured, and will still answer the phone after the trucks leave town.

Why SkyView

Pick a team that can prove it

We're a team of roofing experts working with our roofing partners, Precision Construction and River City Roofing. We take the time to document storm damage the right way, show it to anyone who asks. Construction is performed by licensed Approved Contractors, and you get our full attention from the first inspection through the project.

SkyView is not a contractor, public adjuster or law firm. You stay in charge of your claim. We inspect, document and write the repair scope, and licensed Approved Contractors do the construction.

25+Years in insurance restoration
FreeDamage report. If you later sign a Project Agreement, its fee and cancellation terms are at SkyViewRestore.com/terms.
Whole.Trained inspectors check the entire roof system
USAStorm response nationwide, residential and commercial
Talk to the team

Schedule an inspection or get a bid

Tell us how to reach you. Prefer to skip the form? Call, text or email us directly.

No damage found? We'll give you a Clearance Certificate to keep on file for your insurance and future storm claims.

Best way to reach me

We'll only use your info to contact you about your roof.

Quick questions

More answers

Can insurance refuse to pay because I didn't use their roofer?

Generally, no. Your insurer pays for covered damage under your policy no matter who you hire. If your roofer's price is different from the adjuster's estimate, the difference is worked out with documentation.

I already got a check. Can I still choose my own roofer?

Yes. Getting paid doesn't lock you into any contractor. Have your roofer review the adjuster's estimate so nothing on your roof gets missed before the work starts.

Can my roofer meet the adjuster?

Yes, and it helps. Having your roofer on the roof during the adjuster's inspection means the damage gets pointed out and documented the same day.

Do I need three bids?

Most policies don't require multiple bids, but your adjuster may ask for your contractor's estimate. Check your policy or ask your adjuster if you're not sure.